I did just that against a P2W Fortune Every player. The guy was banishing everything and I had no out since Every kept coming back. At the end my opponent had a big fat Every + 1 Samurai Destroyer and me nothing. Then I put my tuner in attack, set this trap. Next turn the whole field was sent back to deck and the guy had only 4 cards left in his deck, causing him to surrender.
Nearly agree with you.
Still hard to be put into practice I believe. But when it does work, it works very well. No target protection can protect from this, and the opponent has to satisfy the summoning conditions again to re-summon instead of just reviving from the gy.